Amy Allan is a renowned physical medium best known for her role on The Dead Files, where she used her unique abilities to investigate paranormal activity. With over 15 years of experience on the show, Amy built a dedicated fanbase, offering insights into supernatural phenomena that traditional investigators couldn’t explain.
However, in 2023, she shocked fans when she departed from the show, leading to speculation about the reasons behind her exit. Now, Amy is on a different journey—focusing on her mental health, personal healing, and rebuilding her lifeafter years of intense paranormal investigations.
Amy Allan’s Early Life and Career in the Paranormal World
Amy’s fascination with the paranormal began at a young age when she claimed to have had her first supernatural experiences. Over the years, she worked with parapsychologists, spiritualists, and investigators, refining her ability to communicate with spirits.
Before joining television, Amy collaborated with law enforcement agencies and private individuals, assisting in cases where paranormal activity was suspected. Her extensive experience made her the perfect fit for The Dead Files, a show that paired her with retired NYPD homicide detective Steve DiSchiavi to uncover haunted histories.
The Dead Files: Amy Allan’s 15-Year Journey on the Show
Amy joined The Dead Files in 2011, and the show quickly gained popularity due to its unique investigative format. Unlike traditional ghost-hunting programs, The Dead Files combined:
✔ Steve DiSchiavi’s detective work – Researching historical and factual evidence of hauntings.
✔ Amy Allan’s psychic investigations – Conducting spirit walkthroughs to communicate with entities.
This dual approach set the show apart, and Amy became a key figure in the paranormal community. She would often sketch spirits she encountered, revealing eerie and sometimes terrifying details about the ghosts she believed haunted certain locations.
For years, Amy dedicated herself to helping people understand and cope with hauntings, offering psychic insights that traditional investigators could not. However, as time passed, she became increasingly vocal about her dissatisfaction with the way the show was handled behind the scenes.
Why Did Amy Allan Leave The Dead Files?
Amy’s exit from The Dead Files was officially confirmed in April 2023, when Travel Channel announced that Cindy Kaza would replace her as the show’s medium. Fans were shocked and upset, as Amy had been a staple of the series since its inception.
1. Creative Differences & Frustrations with the Show’s Producers
One of the biggest reasons behind Amy’s departure was ongoing disagreements with the producers. She had been open about how she felt “formatted” and restricted by the show’s structure, preventing her from fully using her abilities as a medium.
In various social media posts, Amy expressed frustration over how she was expected to perform in a pre-scriptedmanner, which she felt did not accurately represent her true abilities. She wanted to have more creative control, but the producers insisted on keeping the format unchanged.
2. Health Struggles and Mental Exhaustion
Another major factor in Amy’s decision to leave was her deteriorating health. Over the years, she has struggled with multiple medical conditions, including:
✔ Complex PTSD (CPTSD) – Resulting from years of intense paranormal work and personal trauma.
✔ Fibromyalgia – A chronic pain condition that caused severe physical discomfort.
✔ Autoimmune issues – Amy has hinted several times at having an autoimmune disease, which made her more vulnerable to infections.
✔ Menopause-related symptoms – She revealed that menopause had been affecting her mental and physical health, leading to emotional distress.
In a 2024 Instagram post, Amy confirmed that she was actively undergoing therapy for CPTSD, describing the process as difficult, scary, and emotionally draining. She also admitted that living alone after leaving the show had been a challenge, further suggesting that her marriage to Rob Traegler may have ended.
3. Personal Life Changes: Hints at Divorce
Although Amy has never publicly confirmed her divorce from Rob Traegler, there are many signs that their marriage has ended. In early 2024, she posted that she had moved and wrote, “Living alone is hard,” which directly suggests that she is no longer with her husband.
Additionally, Amy has focused solely on her dog and personal well-being in recent social media updates, with no mention of Rob. This, combined with her mental health struggles, has led many fans to believe that stress from marital issues may have also played a role in her departure from The Dead Files.
What is Amy Allan Doing Now?
Since leaving The Dead Files, Amy has taken a step back from television and is focusing on healing. She has been transparent about her recovery process, which includes:
✔ Therapy for CPTSD – She calls her therapists “earth angels” and says they are helping her take things step by step.
✔ Yoga & Self-Care – She has incorporated yoga and meditation into her routine to help manage stress and chronic pain.
✔ Medical Appointments – She has been keeping up with doctor and dentist visits, making an effort to prioritize her health.
✔ Adjusting to Life After TV – She admits that after being part of a structured show for 15 years, learning to live independently has been difficult.
Amy continues to interact with her fans online, asking those who identify as sensitives or empaths about their own experiences. While she is no longer investigating paranormal cases on television, her psychic abilities remain an important part of her life, and she may explore new ways to share her gift in the future.
Will Amy Allan Ever Return to TV?
At this point, it is unclear whether Amy will return to television. She has not announced any new projects, and her focus seems to be on recovery and personal well-being.
However, many fans hope that she will eventually return, possibly in a new, less restrictive paranormal show where she has more creative control. For now, she seems to be embracing a quieter life, away from the pressures of reality TV.
Amy Allan’s Leg Injury
Amy Allan, renowned for her role on The Dead Files, suffered a significant ankle injury that required medical intervention. During the treatment, she was administered ketamine for a closed reduction procedure, which led to an unexpected past life regression experience, exacerbating her mental health challenges, including symptoms of PTSD.
After a period of recovery, Amy has recently reported a resurgence of pain and discomfort in the same ankle. She described the current condition:
“It’s pointing right, my heel is clamped, my ankle rotated, my foot is constantly being forced to push down, HARD! That’s simply how it has to be…”
This indicates a severe misalignment affecting her knee, ankle, and foot, leading to considerable discomfort and mobility issues.
To manage the recurring pain, Amy has been engaging in various self-care practices. She mentioned winding down and reducing her reliance on pain medications, specifically referencing the use of Percocet post-surgery.
Additionally, she has been focusing on mental health therapies, practicing yoga, and attending regular medical appointments to aid in her overall recovery.
Amy’s journey underscores the challenges of dealing with chronic pain and the importance of comprehensive self-care strategies in managing long-term health issues.